Friday, October 14, 2005

RACIALLY MOTIVATED SUMMONS DISMISSED

RACIALLY MOTIVATED SUMMONS DISMISSED

Hon. Judge Donald Bogosian
Municipal Judge, New Providence, NJ. Sep. 15, 2005 (10.15 P.M.)

RE: SPRINGFIELD TRANSFER CASE RACIALLY MOTIVATED SUMMONS #
K-047616 NO PARKING 2-6 A. M. ISSUED BY SPRINGFIELD POLICE ON
JULY 20, 05 BY BEING PREJUCICED, INTIMIDATING & COMMUNAL

Honorable Judge Donald Bogosian dismissed the racially motivated Summons # K-047616 against the ill-conceived, ill-motivated, illegal opposition/ protests & misrepresentation of Public Prosecutor Robert Thelander appearing on behalf of the corrupt/communal Springfield Police Chief/Officer. I was representing myself on my own. Honorable Judge upheld my rights to my defense and he further stated that I am entitled to the information requested from the Springfield Police.

Hon. Judge: Mr. Makkar do you feel you have been singled out?

Makkar: Yes Sir.

Hon. Judge: To the Prosecutor Thelander why I was not provided with the
Specific information requested on Aug. 30,2005?

Prosecutor: He asked for carte blanche things and that was turned by you. Well
the only one I got here was the one that was on Sep. 12th which is what, 3 days ago and here we are at trial. (he had replied to 8-30-05 request)

Judge: I am talking about the letter he wrote to the chief of police on Aug. 30th
requesting information from the police department. And what the court had
denied is a number of Subpoenas. Clearly from the tenor of the defendant’s
letters back and forth, it appears that he believes that there was selective
enforcement. Am I correct Sir (To Makkar)?

Makkar: Yes, Sir.

Judge: Since the defendant has raised the issue of selective enforcement and since I think it is important that he have the information available to him, that
since it wasn’t provided and I have no reasonable explanation as to why it wasn’t provided, the court is strongly considering to dismiss the summons. The court did not deny his right to receive certain information to prepare his defense of the ticket. As a result court is dismissing the Complaint.

cc: Hon. Peter Harvey, A.G. NJ (corruption/racism by Springfield Adm. 609 292 3508
Ms. Agudosi, Head Bias Crimes, A.G. Office. Fax: 609 219 6595
Col. Joseph Fuentes, Superintendent, State Police. 609 771 1496
Hon. Mayor & Council Members of Springfield. Fax: 973 912 0538
Devendra Makkar as per the Court Transcript received 10-18-05

Thursday, October 13, 2005

REQUEST FOR TRANSFER TO OTHER COURT

Devendra Makkar

Aug. 10, 2005

Mary Jo Banchansky, Ct. Admin
Springfield Municipal Building

Re: Complaint-Summons # K-047616 No Parking 2-C A.M.
&
My Request for Transfer of these matters listed for Aug. 29th, 2005 to some other
Courts and some other Judge

Dear Ms. Banchansky:

Please be advised that I have filed complaints against the presiding judge Hon. Firsichbaum of this Court with the various state departments for the following reasons:

In the matters of Madan v. Sobel & Sobel v. Madan, SPR 022226 etc. (date of judgment Nov. 29, 2004), the judge has presided over a trial by being biased, partisan, intimidating, unfair, abusive, prejudiced and racially discriminatory to our entire family. Knowingly he has allowed counsel Keith Biebelberg’s false independent observers, false witnesses, false evidences including imaginary view obstruction in his court in these matters. Then he ignored Police Officer Kahora’s Police Brutality against my 2 minor children and myself on the instructions of counsel Keith. On the advise of his friend counsel Keith he imposed a wrong and unqualified translator on my wife Mrs. Rashmi Madan Makkar for a language which both of them do not understand, speak and write. Also again on the fraudulent advise of the corrupt and communal counsel Keith he dismissed our expert’s Accident Reconstruction Report along with the fraudulent/fabricated report of the counsel Keith’s expert. On 3 separate occasions he unlawfully/illegally dismissed Motion for his own Recusal to favor his friend counsel Keith. To make the matters worst the judge himself lied and misrepresented so many times in the open court to favor his friend counsel Keith. Unlawful/illegal/discriminatory/partisan actions of the judge in these matters are contrary to the moral/ethical/professional code of conduct for a judge. That the judges are above law; are not supposed to take sides and they have to respect the doctrine of “Equal Justice to All”. The unlawful/illegal/immoral and unethical/discriminatory actions of Hon. Judge Firsichbaum do not give me any confidence and faith in the Hon. Judge Firsichbaum and the Springfield Municipal Court as well as the Springfield Police under the command of a morally/ethically and professionally corrupt/communal Police Chief William Chisholm.

Aug. 10, 2005 (Page 2)

Moreover the above summons # K-047616 represents bias, prejudice, intimidation, coercion, partisanship, racial discrimination and profiling on the part of Police Chief Chisholm and the officer Dauser I.D. # 604. There are no such signs of No Parking between 2.00 A.M. and 6.00 A.M. on Ashwood Rd. Then there are my other neighbors who always park on the Ashwood and I have proof of that. On top of that I have been living here since 2001 and on number of occasions I have parked outside no such summons were issued then. All of a sudden why I have been singled out that too for an ordinance which is applicable to major roads coming to the town not to a road, which is purely a residential road with a dead end on west side? Why select people who are close to the judge, police chief, mayor and council members are given illegal favors even to make undisclosed amount of money at the risk of human lives and their properties on Ashwood Road?

The same police chief along with the Mayor have allowed an individual to convert his property as link road between Ashwood and Baltursal Golf Club to benefit this individual for an undisclosed amount of money known as PGA truck Gate 3. This has been done without the consent of the residents of Ashwood Rd. and a Variance from the Board of Adjustment of the town. Ashwood Rd. has been converted into a commercial highway with commercial traffic practically all day and at odd hours of the night and very early morning putting human lives and their properties to all kinds of danger including environmental pollution and disturbance during sleeping hours. No safety measures like speed breakers or extra signs “Watch for Children at Play” has been installed by the Police Department to stop the 18 wheelers with trailers, big trucks and other vehicles to stop them doing 30-40 MPH on purely a residential road with a dead end on west side with legal speed limit of 25 MPH.

Since July 4th, 2005 our entire family is the victims of hate crimes and racial discrimination. See Police reports # 2005-32631, 3937, 4034, 4254, 4713, 4780, 4837, 4934 and the summons in question K-047616. (See enclosed Hate Crimes/discrimination)
We suspect Hon. Judge Firsichbaum, Police Chief Chisholm, Mayor Mullman, Ex-Mayor Harelik, Counsel Keith Biebelberg and our neighbor Steven Sobel are behind these crimes against us, for reporting against them to the various depts. for their unlawful, illegal, corrupt and communal actions in the matters of Madan v. Sobel and Sobel v. Madan and corruption in PGA and Fire House Deals.

Then on Aug. 8th, 2005 when I was protesting outside the Municipal Building to demand Resignation of Hon. Judge Firsichbaum and Police Chief Chisholm on account of unlawful/illegal/communal moral, ethical and professional issues. The judge/his office called the state police citing concern for his security. Sgt. David Chamber who met me that day was very skeptical about this call. He further added, “I am a hard working, law abiding, a strong believer of non-violence decent man. He is doing his duty because the Judge’s security comes under his department. Again said that chief and judge are not going to resign on my demands and I should not hurt myself by going on hunger strikes.

Aug. 10, 2005 (Page 3)

I told him if they do not want to resign let the police chief take proper disciplinary actions against the guilty Police Officers and the judge should transfer the case Madan v. Sobel etc. to be reopened by a different judge and recommend to the proper authorities to revoke the license of Mr. Keith Biebelberg to Practice Law in the State of New Jersey.

I am highly concerned and very much worried about the safety, security and lives of my family and myself from all these above named individuals who are very powerful/corrupt/communal and will not hesitate to do harmful things to my family and myself. Ex-Mayor Clara Harelik last year threatened me over the phone, “You have annoyed lot of people in the town. You may not like the end results”.


Certainly the end results are not to our likings according to her but the final end results have yet to come which may not be to the likings of all of the above named individuals. There can be delay in the justice in the House of God but we will certainly get the justice. Fortunately the taxpayers/residents of Springfield will definitely like that justice. There is an authority above them in the state and federal government along with the God who can boot them out of the power/positions and some of them may be prosecuted on criminal charges including perjuries/corruption

Under the above circumstances and risk to my life, security and well being physically/mentally I refuse to be present in the court of Hon. Judge Firsichbaum and the Municipal Court of Springfield. The judge along with the above named individuals jointly/separately openly/under cover along with his knowledge of law and power can inflict physical and mental injuries on me. I am already suffering from the pain and agony he has inflicted along with the above named individuals on my entire family and me. I refuse to take it any more for the sake of my own and my family’s safety, security and physical as well as mental/emotional well being. With this letter I make an appeal to the Hon. Peter Harvey the Attorney General of NJ to provide my family and myself proper security. This should also be treated as criminal complaints against the above named individuals who we suspect are behind the hate crimes and racial discrimination against my entire family and myself.

So kindly transfer the above matters to some other Court and some other judge in the state of New Jersey. Thank you for your attention to this matter.
Very truly yours,
Devendra Makkar

cc: Hon. Deborah Poritz, Chief Justice of NJ. F 609-292 3320, 984 6968, 292 4255
Hon. Christopher Christe, United States Attorney. F 973 645 2702
Hon. Peter Harvey, Attorney General of NJ. F 609 292 3508
Ms. Agudosi, Head of Biased Crimes, A.G. office NJ. F 609 219 3454
Hon. Walter Barisonek, Judge Superior Court union County. F 908 659 367

Aug. 26, 2005

Mr. Robert Smith
Assistant Director
Municipal Court Services Division
Fax: 609 292 4255

Re: Racially Motivated Complaint-Summons # K-047616 No Parking 2-C A.M.
My Request to transfer these matters listed for Aug. 29th, 2005 at 5.00 P.M. at
Springfield Municipal Court to some other Courts/Judge dated Aug. 10th, 2005

Dear Mr. Smith:

Please be advised I refuse to be present in the Court of Hon. Steven W. Firsichbaum, J.M.C. Springfield Municipal Court. A request for transfer to some other Court/Judge of the above matters was made to the Court Administrator Mary Jo Banchansky on Aug. 10th, 2005 citing the reasons in detail for this request. A copy of the same was faxed to your office and Hon. Chief Justice office also.

Looking at my past experience with Springfield Municipal Court the Ct. Adm. Banchansky has a habit of calling on the day of appearance between 3.00 P.M. to 4.00 P.M., “That the Judge has denied your request, you have to be present by 5.00 P.M.”

Since I suspect Hon. Judge Firsichbaum is behind our family’s victimization to racially motivated hate crimes, I refuse to be present in his Court. For the sake of my life, my security and physically/mentally well being I will not be present on Aug. 29th, 2005 at 5.00 P.M. in the Springfield Municipal Court. At the same time I am willing to be present in any other Court of New Jersey under any other Judge as directed by your office in reference to the above matters. Thank you for your kind attention to this matter.

Sincerely,

Devendra Makkar

cc: Hon. Chief Justice Deborah Poritz. Fax: 609 292 3320 & 609 984 6968
Hon. Christopher Christie, United states Attorney. F 973 645 2702
Hon. Peter Harvey, Attorney General of NJ. F 609 292 3508
Hon. Walter Barisonek, Judge Superior Court Union County. F 908 659 3670
Ms. Agudosi, Head of Biased Crimes, A.G. Office of NJ. F 609 219 6595
Mr. Michael D’Ecclessis, Municipal Div. Manager union County. F 908 659 4198
Ms. Mary Jo Banchansky, Ct. Adm. Springfield Municipal Court. F 973 912 2287
Mr. William Chisholm, Chief of Police Township of Springfield. F 973 912 0538

Tuesday, October 11, 2005

RACIAL DISCRIMINATION PROTEST RALLY 8-13-06

Aug. 29, 2005

Ms. Macrina Carra, Ct. Adm.
New Providence Municipal Court

Re: Springfield Twp. transfer case Racially Motivated Summons # K-047616, Request for new trial date and some records from the Springfield Police Department.

Dear Ms. Carra:

Respectfully I would like to submit that I am the Manager of a Check Cashing Store in Irvington. I am the only male member in this store. Thursdays and Fridays are our very busy days and we close at 8.00 P.M. After that I do need 30-40 minutes to reconcile cash. On both these days we do carry substantial amount of cash on premises.

The trial date Sep. 29, 2005 is a Thursday that can create security risk for the business as well as for the female staff working at the store. If it is at all possible for the Honorable Court to grant me a new date for any other day of the week except Thursday and Friday, I will be highly obliged.

Further I request the Honorable Court to call for the following documents from the Springfield Police Department and copies of the same should also be provided to me well in advance of the appointed Court Date:

Number of summons issued under 2 –6 A.M. (7-14) for the year 2004 on Ashwood Rd. and Statile Ct. (Please note Statile Ct. is a cul-de-sac facing my property on Ashwood Rd.

Number of summons issued under 2-6 A.M. (7-14) for the period Jan. 1, 2005 to June 30, 2005 on Ashwood Rd. and Statile Ct.

Copies of all summons issued under 2-6 A.M. (7-14) for the period July 1, 2005 to Aug. 28, 2005 on Ashwood Rd. and Statile Ct.

Thank you for your anticipated help in this matter.


Aug. 30, 2005

Chief of Police Mr. William Chisholm
Officer Donald Dauser # 604
Municipal Building of Springfield,

Re: Springfield Twp. transfer case Racially Motivated Summons # K-047616 to The
Municipal Court of New Providence. New trial date of Sep. 15th, 05 at 9.30 P.M. &
Request for some documents/information from your department.

Dear Sir:

Please note the new trial date for the above-referred matters is Sep. 15th, 2005 at 9.30 P.M. at Municipal Court of New Providence. Further a request for the following documents was made to the Court Administrator on Aug. 29th, 2005, who has advised me to take up this issue directly with your department. Please be advised I need the following documents well ahead of the trial date of Sep. 15th, 2005 to prepare my defense as well as to prove that you/your department is indulging in racial discrimination and profiling.

It was your department who filed a false/fabricated/fictitious report on July 15, 2005 with the State Police that I was video filming the DMV facility in Springfield with some kind of anti national motives. Sgt. David Chambers from the State Police interrogated me on July 18, 2005 in the presence of Sgt. McNanny of Springfield in the chambers of the Municipal Building.

Documents required from your department:

Number of Summons issued under 2-6 A.M. (7-14) for the year 2004 on Ashwood Rd. and Statile Ct. As you are fully aware Statile Ct. is a cul-de-sac facing my property.

Number of Summons issued under 2-6 A.M. (7-14) for the period Jan. 1st, 2005 to Aug. 28th, 2005 on Ashwood Rd. and Statile Ct.

Copies of all Summons issued under 2-6 A.M. (7-14) for the period July 1st, 2005 to Aug. 28th, 2005 on Ashwood Rd. and Statile Ct.

Thank you for your anticipated help in this matter.

Sep. 12, 2005

Chief of Police Mr. William Chisholm
Officer Donald Dauser # 604

Re: Springfield Twp. transfer case Racially Motivated Summons # K-047616 to The
Municipal Court of New Providence. New trial date of Sep. 15th, 05 at 9.30 P.M. &
Request for some documents/information from your department on 8-30-05.

Dear Sir:

Please note in addition to the documents/information already requested on Aug. 30, 2005 I need the following information/documents. Please be advised I need the following documents well ahead of the trial date of Sep. 15th, 2005 to prepare my defense as well as to prove that you/your department is indulging in racial discrimination and profiling as well as keeping their eyes closed to the hate crimes against me and my entire family since May 21, 2004 by some individuals/residents known to Elected/Non-Elected Officials of this town. All these individuals are a disgrace to the beautiful community of the town, whom we honor, admire and respect for their customs and values.

Documents required from your department:

1. Copy of the Town Ordinance showing Ashwood Rd. under the 2-6 A.M. No Parking Zone. Why no such sign is posted on Ashwood Rd.? Also a Copy of the Rules or Criteria to declare a particular road as No Parking 2-6 A.M. road.

Copy of the Permission Granted to the owner of PGA Truck Gate 3 to convert Ashwood Rd. into a Commercial Highway for more then 2 months for huge financial gains to the property owner. And may be direct or indirect favors, consultancy fees, and financial gains to some of the Elected/Non-Elected Officials of this town. Also the copy of the Ordinance or Rules under which this permission was granted by endangering the life, security and properties of the residents of Ashwood Rd., Statile Ct. and Sherwood Rd. for this illegal/inhuman permission granted by you/your department and the other elected/non-elected town officials.

Number of Egg Throwing incidents on vehicles parked inside the driveways of properties on Ashwood Rd. and Statile Ct. for the year 2004 and from Jan. 1, 2005 to Aug. 31, 2005.

Number of incidents reported for Properties Vandalized on Ashwood Rd. and Statile Ct. for the year 2004 and from Jan. 1, 2005 to Aug.31, 2005.

Number of incidents reported involving Illegal Fireworks right next to some one’s property and parked vehicle at odd hours on Ashwood Rd. and Statile Ct. for the year 2004 and from Jan. 1, 2005 to Aug. 31, 2005.

Number of incidents of Window Breaking of vehicles parked inside the driveways of properties on Ashwood Rd. and Statile Ct. for the year 2004 and from Jan. 1, 2005 to Aug. 31, 2005.

Number of Motor Vehicle Accidents Reported on Ashwood Rd. and Statile Ct. from 2000 to 2004 and from Jan.1, 2005 to Aug. 31, 2005.

Number of incident reported by the residents of Ashwood Rd. and Statile Ct. for threatening, intimidating, abusive and racist phone calls, letters and e-mails for the year 2004 and from Jan. 1, 2005 to Aug. 31, 2005.

Copy of the False/Fabricated/Defamatory Complaints filed by you/your department to the State Police that I was indulging in some kind of an anti-national activities. On the basis of these Complaints the State Police Sgt. David Chambers in the presence of Sgt. McNanny of Springfield interrogated me on July 18, 2005 at Municipal Chambers of Springfield.

Thank you for your anticipated help in these matters and assuring you of my best cooperation at all times.


cc: Honorable Christopher Christie, United States Attorney. Fax: 973 645 2702
Hon. Peter Harvey, A.G. (Corruption/Racism by Springfield Adm. 609 292 3508
Ms. Agudosi, Head of Biased Crimes, A.G. Office, Trenton. Fax: 609 219 6595
Col. Joseph Fuentes, Superintendent, State Police, Trenton. Fax: 609 771 1496
Ms. Macrina Carra, CMCA, Municipal Court of New Providence. Fax: 908 665 9873
Mr. Robert Thelander, Esq., Municipal Prosecutor, New Providence. 908 273 2556

Sunday, October 09, 2005

PROSECUTOR REFUSE TO GIVE INFO

Sep. 1, 2005

Ms. Macrina Carra, CMCA
New Providence Municipal Court

Re: Racially Motivated Summons # K-047616, unreadable hand written fax message of 9-01-05 of Prosecutor Robert Thelander and your phone call for my written statement as requested by the Hon. Judge and my letters of Aug. 29th & 31st, 2005.

Dear Ms. Carra:

Let the Prosecutor Mr. Thelander be advised the information requested # 1, 2 & 3 in my letter of Aug. 29, 2005 has all the relevance to the above racially motivated summons issued to me by the Springfield Police. This information is required to prepare my defense and prove that the Springfield Police under the Chief William Chisholm is biased, prejudiced, unfair, morally/ethically corrupt and racist. I have enough proofs to prove it that the above summons were issued to me by singling out me and is the part of our victimization to Hate Crimes and Racial Discrimination by the Police, Court, Administration and few residents of Springfield. (Details Enclosed)

Since Dec. 2004 I have been requesting the Resignation of Hon. Judge Steven Firsichbaum and Chief William Chisholm on ethical, moral and professional issues in the matters of Madan v. Sobel and Sobel v. Madan, SPR 022226 etc. to various state departments/agencies. Then to demand their Resignations I have twice gone on a hunger strike on July 4th, 2005 and Aug. 8, 2005 outside the Municipal Building of Springfield. Since June 27th, 2005 my entire family and myself are the victims of serial Hate Crimes and racial discrimination under the watchful eyes of the Springfield Police, Administration and Elected Representatives. (Details Enclosed)

We suspect Hon. Judge Firsichbaum, Councilwomen Clara Harelik, Police Chief Chisholm, Officers Quirk and Kahora, Attorney Keith Beibelberg, his client Steven Sobel, his false witnesses Mr. Barry Farbstein, Ms. Leslie Kasten, Ms. Lisa Glennon and his false Repair Estimate Maker Dobbs Auto body are behind our victimization. Unfortunately they have the full support of the Administration and the Elected Officials.

Councilwoman Clara Harelik when she was Mayor made a terrorist threat over the phone to me related to then court case. “You have annoyed lot of people in the town, you may not like the end results”. The matter was reported to the Union County Judge and the town attorney at that time, till to date no action has been taken against her.
Page 2

I would appreciate it if you would arrange for the subpoenaing of Councilwoman Clara Harelik, Officer Quirk and Officer Kahora also for the Sep. 15, 2005 court hearing. This is in addition to the request made for the subpoenaing of Sgt. David Chambers and Sgt. McNanny on Aug. 31, 2005. All of them are relevant in the above matters.

Officer Quirk is responsible for filling a biased and racially discriminatory accident report on 5-21-04 in which my wife and my minor son were hit by my neighbor Mr. Steven Sobel. He totally ignored the visible physical damage to vehicles, weather conditions, distance, and profile of both drivers. Mr. Sobel’s removing all the evidences from the scene of the accident was an indication that he is a liar and a habitual traffic laws violator. Being V. P. of a Corporation he had full knowledge and understanding of what he did that day. Chief Chisholm refused to take a complaint against Officer Quirk or to amend his report and refused to meet us in person, is a proof of his racial bias, prejudice and inhuman approach towards the victims, a woman and her minor son.

Officer Kahora on Sep. 20, 2004 physically stopped me and my 2 minor children (age 5 & 9 then) with her one hand on her gun from entering the Courtroom during the recess to meet their mother. At that time counsel Keith Biebelberg his client Steven Sobel, his false witnesses, his false/planted independent observers were eating and drinking inside the Courtroom. Disgustingly according to my wife one of the so-called female Independent Observer was hand feeding Mr. Steven Sobel. Under this same officer during the hearing of some other matters counsel Keith Beibelberg was keeping his hand on the back of the so called female Independent Observer and his entire group was talking to each other. You allow people to break the decorum of the Court because they are from your community or known to you and then physically stop at Gun Point 2 minor children accompanied by their father from entering the Courtroom during recess is not Racial Discrimination? Chief Chisholm again took no action against his another officer for Police Brutality and Racial Discrimination. Rather Officer Kahora is rewarded and can be seen posted outside the Elementary Schools of Springfield.

Councilwoman Clara Harelik for making terrorist threats to me and shielding Chief William Chisholm and Hon. Judge Steven Firsichbaum who conspired with counsel Keith Beibelberg and his gang to prove that my wife is blind, brain damaged and has no credibility against his habitual traffic law breaker client, false witnesses, false independent observers, false evidence makers, wrong translator and imaginary view obstruction created specifically for my wife by him. On the issue of my minor son’s injuries and his representation by me. Hon. Judge Firsichbaum told me after 4 months, “He is not an injury Court and I can not represent him”.

All these people are responsible for racial discrimination and hate crimes against my entire family and me since May 21, 2004. The above referred Racially Motivated Summons # K- 047616 is a part of those crimes. According to these morally, ethically and professionally corrupt/communal individuals they are the majority in the town, so they are the law. Do you agree with this?

Thank you for your attention to this matter.


Encl.: List of Hate Crimes & events of Racial Discrimination since June 27, 2005. Please note these are in addition to the one committed against my entire family and myself since the M.V. crash from May 21, 2004 to Nov. 29, 2004 in the matters of SPR 02226 etc. (Date of Judgment Nov. 29, 2004)

Resignation Request to Hon. Judge Firsichbaum, June 17, 2005.

Resignation Request of the judge to Hon. Chief Justice of S.C. July 28, 2005.

Court Adm. Springfield for transfer of Summons # K-047616. Aug. 10, 2005.

Mayor of Springfield on judge & police chief’s resignation. June 01, 2005.

Renewed Resignation Request to Chief Chisholm. Aug. 22, 2005.

Punjab Express & Local Talk Weekly Newspaper Report on our fight against corruption by attorneys/judges/elected and non-elected officials.

Total No. Of Pages including this letter 21

Sep. 9, 2005

Ms. Macrina Carra, Cmca
New providence Municipal Court

Re: Springfield Twp. Transfer Case Racially Motivated Summons # K-047616
And Your Letter dated Sep. 7, 2005 on Subpoenaed Witnesses

Dear Ms. Carra:

With due respect to Hon. Judge Bogosian, I disagree with him for his denial to subpoena certain people who are very critical to my defense. The above Summons is part of the series of Hate Crimes and Racial Discrimination committed against my entire family and myself since May 21, 2004. With their testimony I will be able to prove beyond any reasonable doubt that Springfield Police Department under the morally, ethically and professionally corrupt/communal Chief Chisholm is very much responsible for the victimization of my entire family and myself since May 21, 2004.

Under his very command my residential road with a dead end on one side was converted into a Commercial Highway. In a MV crash Officer Quirk can ignore visible physical damage in the ratio of 1:8, can ignore Mr. Sobel a well qualified V.P. of a Corp. destroying the critical evidences, can ignore distance, can ignore weather/road conditions, can ignore profile of both drivers and trauma/injury to a minor as well as to a housewife. This officer can file a biased, prejudiced, wrong and discriminatory report to favor Mr. Sobel and gets full support of his Chief Chisholm and then Mayor Harelik for doing that.

His another Officer Kahora can take illegal orders from a unauthorized person counsel Keith during recess; can physically stop with her one hand on her gun 2 minor children age 5 & 9 accompanied by their father from meeting their mother in the Courtroom. It was when the Courtroom was used as an Ethnic Club or Private Dining Room by counsel Keith and his group members with Officer Kahora providing them security. During the proceedings of some other matter Officer Kahora can ignore counsel Keith and his group members using the Courtroom as personal living room. Breaking all the decorum and rules of the Court by talking to each other and sitting inappropriately.

Under his very command his department can file a false/fabricated and defamatory report against me with the State Police. That I was indulging in some kind of anti national activities. Raising doubts about my integrity, my patriotism, my honesty and my loyalty towards my own country United States of America. A person who has been helping the Law Enforcement Agencies by risking his life and money in their fight against financial crimes and identity frauds since 1999. Number of times who has given leads to these Agencies which has materialized in arrest of individuals as well as whole gangs. For that reason I need the testimony of Sgt. David Chambers who interrogated me in the presence of Sgt. McNanny within 72 hours of the complaint by his department.

Page 2

Councilwoman Clara Harelik, an attorney by profession when she was the Mayor ignored the complaints against the corrupt/racist Police Chief and the Judge. Rather made terrorist threats to me on Aug. 16, 2004 that “I will not like the end results”. These were the end results she was talking; Officer Kahora with her hand on her gun physically stopping me and my 2 minor children, counsel Keith to save Mr. Sobel conspired against my wife with the Hon. Judge Firsichbaum along with his false/invented/tutored witnesses Mr. Barry Farbstein, Ms. Lisa Glennon and Ms. Leslie Kasten along with a false/fabricated repair estimate maker Dobbs Auto Body (all residents of Springfield and belongs to her community) on the biased/wrong/unfair report of Officer Quirk to prove that my wife is blind/brain damaged/not credible in the Court and has hit Mr. Sobel.

Counsel Keith also prevailed in imposing a wrong translator on my wife and creating a non-existent imaginary view obstruction for her in the Court. Unfortunately the judge acted in a biased, partisan, unethical, immoral and non-secular manner during the entire proceedings. (SPR 022226 etc) He openly favor counsel Keith and lied on several issues for his benefit and ruled, “No party can file appeal to his judgment” on Nov. 29, 04

May be on Aug. 16, 2004 Councilwoman Harelik was also referring to illegal Subpoena Summons illegally served to me in my bed, future damage/vandalization to our property & car, fireworks at odd hours to scare our children, threatening/obscene/racist letters/phone calls and again the Racially motivated Summons K-047616 to scare me?

In light of all of the above I have strong objections to Hon. Judge’s ruling on the issue of Subpoenaed Witnesses. The Hon. Judge is denying my rights to my defense and stopping me from exposing the corruption/racism by the Springfield Town Hall.

Once again I make a humble request to the Hon. Judge to reconsider his decision. Let the Hon. Judge accept this letter-brief with the enclosed Hate Crimes and Racial Discrimination against my family and me since May 21, 2004 in chronological order. This may be helpful to the Honorable Judge in its decision to uphold the sanctity and integrity of the Court and the doctrine of, “Equal Justice to all”. His decision will also reflect his stand on corruption/racism in general as well as by the Springfield Town Hall.
Thank you for your kind attention to this matter.


Encl.: Hate Crimes & Racial Discrimination since May 21, 2004 in chronological order.

Sep. 15, 2005

Ms. Macrina Carra, Ct. Adm.
New Providence Municipal Court

Re: Springfield Twp. Transfer case Racially Motivated Summons # K-047616
&
Refusal/Inability of Springfield Police Department in Providing Certain Documents
Related to this Racial Profiling/Discrimination necessary for my defense

Dear Ms. Carra:

Since the Springfield Police has refused or has intentionally failed to provide me with certain documents requested to them on Aug. 30, 2005 & Sep. 12, 2005. So it is my understanding that the sole issue will be my appearance only before the court on Sep. 15, 2005 at 9.30 P.M. tonight. To be clear no testimony will be given by any party or witnesses (expert or lay) regarding any other aspects of this case until the new trial date as decided by the Honorable Judge.

Please be advised under the constitution I have the right to defend myself and prove the above Summons # K-047616 are part of my self and my entire family’s on going victimization since May 21, 2004 for hate crimes and racial discrimination by the Elected/Non-Elected Officials and their few friends/residents of Springfield. The Subpoenaed Officers Quirk, Kahora and Dauser may have acted under the corrupt/communal influence of the Police Chief Chisholm and other Elected/Non-Elected Officials responsible for our ongoing victimization since May 21, 2004. Sgt. David Chambers has interrogated me on false/fabricated/discriminatory/defamatory report of Springfield Police in the presence of Sgt. McNanny. Councilwoman Harelik when she was Mayor made a terrorist threat to me that I will not like the end results. As a law abiding responsible citizen of this Country it is my civic duty to expose corruption and racism by Elected/Non-Elected Officials. All these named individuals are very critical to my defense and my ability to prove hate crimes and racial discrimination by them. So please make sure these Subpoenaed witnesses are present on the future trial date.

Thank you for your kind attention in this regard.

Sep. 15, 2005
4.45 P.M.

Ms. Macrina Carra, CMCA
Municipal Court of New Providence

Re: Springfield Twp. Transfer case Racially Motivated Summons # K-047616
My letter of Sep. 09, 2005, Sep. 15, 2005 & information/documents from
Springfield Police requested on Aug. 30, 2005 & Sep. 12, 2005

Dear Ms. Carra:

This is in reference to your phone call earlier and your good selves was advised to put in writing whatever you have to say on the above referred matters.

Please be advised I do not take any verbal commands or orders or instructions in the above-referred matters. I must have the information/documents & Subpoena Witnesses before I walk into the Courtroom. All the issues raised in my correspondences must be addressed in writing as per applicable laws before any trial takes place. I must have the opportunity and enough time to take legal advise on that. I am not interested in a trial by ambush or deceit or under any kind of prejudice or discrimination or intimidation.

Thank you for your attention to this matter.

Very truly yours,


Devendra Makkar


cc: Hon. Peter Harvey, A.G. NJ (corruption/racism by Springfield Adm. 6092923508
Hon. Joan Robinson Gross, P.J.M.C. Fax: 908 231 7632
Ms. Agudosi, Head of Biased Crimes, A.G. office, Trenton. Fax: 609 219 6595
Hon. Mayor & Council Members, Springfield. 973 912 2277
Chief of Police William Chisholm, Springfield. 973 912 0538
Mr. Robert Thelander, Esq., Municipal Prosecutor. 908 273 2556